Love for the Moon Over Manifest

Moon Over Manifest by Clare Vanderpool

My rating: 4 of 5 stars


One of those sweet and intriguing stories that makes you feel torn between whether you like reading the flashbacks better or the present. And you gotta love twists at the end.

I loved the mystery surrounding the fortune teller/story teller and how in the end, most of the narrative turns out to be her story. Was that too much of a spoiler? I hope not.

Being the English major/writer nerd that I am, I have to put a plug in for the narrative itself. There are multiple layers of story. Each character has a story that weaves throughout all of the others. It's intricate, it's...Dickens-esque, even. You get the spunky girl on the cover telling her story, you get the fortune teller, you get the news writer, you get the soldier writing home, and... you also get the ultra mysterious Jinx character, who I believe never actually tells his story from the 1st person, but who you can't help but identify with in some degree.

(*Slight spoiler alert here.*)

No need to read Just Ella, but choose Ella Enchanted

Don't read

 I wanted something flighty and fast and that's what this is. Plus it reminded me distantly of the Newberry Honor book by Gail Carson Levine Ella Enchanted, which was my favorite book in middle school before the movie absolutely destroyed it.

I guess that's what Haddix was counting on. Riding on the misplaced associatons with another book. But the coattails of Ella Enchanted would not be ridden.

Decent female narrator voice. But, under-developed plot, overly predictable characters, and only a cute-ish romance that tries too hard to be... real.

I'd recommend it only to 13 year old girls. Maybe. But I think even they will get a much more rewarding reading experience from Ella Enchanted. Now there's a cute, chick-flicky book with some sass and just enough depth.

READ